
I finished Myst IV: Revelation on Friday. I bought it back in March when I got my first DVD drive for my computer. I installed it to make sure it worked, but never actually played it, since I had no time for such things. As GenCon approached, it was ever more important to work on art, and Myst would definitely get in the way of that. Once I got back from GenCon, I figured I deserved a break from the mad rush to make art so I could finally play it.
Alas, it was rather disappointing. I became frustrated from time to time and sought assistance from the built-in help. Unfortunately, as often happens with the built-in help, I learned things that I didn't want to. I wanted gentle hints about specific areas or puzzles. Clicking on the wrong part of the map because I was lost and getting hints about places I hadn't reached yet was really upsetting. Reading in a hint that "you'll need to solve this to help you with puzzle Z later on" was also annoying. I didn't want to know about puzzle Z, damnit! The most disappointing parts were those puzzles for which I needed major hints, and realized upon reading the hints that I would never have solved said puzzles on my own. One of them refers to a note on a piece of paper you're supposed to find that I swear isn't really in the game at all. Second most disappointing were those puzzles that I had figured out correctly, but the way you implement the solution was so tricky or badly implemented that I thought I had it wrong. Auditory puzzles drive me nuts. "Oh, I did have the sequence right...I just didn't hold the notes for long enough." Grr.
Maybe I have inaccurate memories of the previous games, but I remember the acting in the video sequences being way, way better in the other games. I remember the ones in Riven being pretty good. I recall Exile being a little cheesy at times, but I don't think it was as bad as the stuff in Revelation.
I gather that there's a Myst V, but it seems to have almost universally bad reviews, many of which cite specific flaws that make it sound very unappealing. I think when I get some free time I'll just replay Riven and Exile instead. Oh, well.